Bob Beltz

Senior Minister


Bob Beltz has served as the Senior Minister of Valley Mills Christian Church since October of 2013.   From 2002 – 2007, he served as the Worship Minister, coming back in 2013 to follow God’s call in his current role.  Born and raised near Daytona Beach, Florida, he graduated from Florida Christian College of Kissimmee in 1983, where he met and married his college sweetheart, Robin.  They have two girls, Amanda and Kristi, who are both married and serving the Lord in vocational ministry.  They are blessed with two grandsons, Oliver and Tucker, and two granddaughters, Harvey Rose, and Ellie Joy.

One of Bob’s favorite scriptures is found in 2 Corinthians 12:9 – But He said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.”  Therefore I will boast all the more gladly about my weaknesses, so that Christ’s power may rest on me.

Some of Bob’s favorite leisure activities include mowing the lawn, riding on his 4 wheeler, spending time with family, and attending various auto racing events.  One thing people may not know is that several years ago Bob won 1st place in a “Faster Pastor” School Bus Race at Lincoln Park Speedway, Putnamville, IN.

Tanya Henthorn

Children’s Minister


Tanya Henthorn joined Valley Mills in October of 2019 as the Children’s Minister.  She is a graduate of Lincoln Christian College and has over 20 years of Children’s Ministry experience in Illinois, Ohio, and Indiana.  Tanya has a deep passion for connecting with kids as well as their parents and walking alongside of the family to equip and encourage them in their child’s spiritual journey.

She has been married to Keith for 15 years and when they have down-time they enjoy sports (Go Cardinals!), being involved in Special Olympics with their son Shaun, and traveling to new places with Autism on the Seas.

Craig Rice

Youth Minister


Craig Rice joined Valley Mills in April of 2020 and serves as our Student Minister. Craig is originally from Brazil, Indiana where he spent most of his life. He attended Milligan College receiving a degree in Bible with an emphasis in Youth Ministry. Craig has been married to his amazing wife Caroline for two years. They recently had a baby boy named Peter. Craig has a passion for student ministry and reaching the lost for Christ. In his spare time Craig enjoys playing basketball, biking, playing disc golf, fishing, watching sports, and being with his family. Craig has spent the past two years serving as the Student Minister at Christway Christian Church in Augusta, GA. Craig loves everything about student ministry from the trips to building relationships to preaching and teaching the students about God’s word. Craig looks forward to serving Christ alongside his new church family at Valley Mills Christian Church.

Robin Paul

Ministry and Counseling Coordinator


Robin Paul has been on staff with us since 2015; she serves as our part-time Ministry & Counseling Coordinator. Robin is a Licensed Clinical Social Worker who desires to use her Spirit-given capacity in exhortation to serve God by motivation others to action through relationship and helping identify practical steps for problem-solving. Organizationally, Robin has several years of supervisory and management experience. She is a strong believer that “church” is not a place you go, but something to “be”. Robin loves focusing on community collaborations, and has a heart for helping families affected by addictions and loss. Robin & her husband, Phil, enjoy spending their non-work time boating, fishing, and spending time with family. They have a teenage son who is very active in competitive swimming, and their daughter and her husband have blessed them with two incredible grandsons. Their family also includes Squiggles, an eight pound shitzu who loves riding on the helm of their boat like he is on the Titanic.

Tanya Gonterman

Administrative Coordinator


Tanya Gonterman has been on staff since 2014 and serves as our Administrative Coordinator.  She is married to her high school sweetheart, Todd (who you may see on Sunday mornings behind the drums as part of the worship team). They have two children, a wonderful son and daughter-in-law and are blessed with two sweet grandsons.  Tanya grew up in Louisville, KY but has traveled extensively during her husband’s 22-year career in the United States Navy — their time living in Guam was one of her favorite (and farthest!) places to live.  She enjoys the outdoors and especially witnessing God’s beautiful creations while exploring Indiana with her husband on their Harley Davidson motorcycle.

Tanya has a heart for hospitality and welcoming newcomers and can be found most Sundays serving at the Welcome Center Table — be sure to stop by and introduce yourself!

Heather Skaggs

Valley Mills Christian Preschool Director


Heather Skaggs serves as the Director of the Valley Mills Christian Preschool.  Heather has been married to her high school sweetheart, Keith, for 25 years.  She has three beautiful children; Carissa attends Valley Mills Christian Preschool, Ragan is a sophomore in high school, and Austin is a senior in college.  As a mother, Heather wants to make a difference in how we teach and care for our children.  She is an avid believer that it takes a village to raise a child, and that teaching is not just a job, but a passion.  Heather has over 15 years of experience in the educational field, with a degree in business management and various certifications in preschool readiness.

Heather has a deep desire to love, nurture, and inspire children from the moment they enter the preschool until it’s time for them to go home.   She is determined to build strong foundations for our children that will equip them to be successful future adults.

Casey Harvey

Part-Time Administrative Assistant


Casey Harvey joined our staff as a summer assistant supporting our children’s programming initiatives in 2016 and 2017.  Casey has since added a few hours of her time as an ongoing part-time administrator to help us coordinate our “Connections” Ministry (greeters, ushers) and assist in managing our church database.  Please look for Casey’s welcoming smile around our greeter stations on Sunday mornings as she coordinates many busy volunteers.

Casey has been blessed to be married to Jason for 4 years and they have a beautiful daughter named Everly Grace.  She shares that she feels blessed to be serving the Lord with her amazing church family at Valley Mills Christian Church.  The Lord led Casey into teaching elementary school 14 years ago, and she has taught several different grade levels with kindergarten as her primary focus over the past 8 years.  She is a full-time Kindergarten teacher at Plainfield School System.

Joe McNeil

Spiritual Growth Coordinator


Joe McNeil joined Valley Mills in November 2017 and serves on staff as our Spiritual Growth Coordinator.  He previously served as our Interim Worship Minister.  Joe has been playing music in various ministries for over 20 years, and he believes that true worship is pouring out your heart and soul to God and truly being authentic and honest in His presence.  He also finds great joy in serving!  He is married to his amazing and beautiful wife Tomesia, who also has 20 years of music ministry experience. They have 3 talented and extraordinary children: Solomon, Alex, and Ivy. Joe is passionate about music, using gifts and talents to serve, movies, and hobby board gaming. Joe owns White Flag Games in Mooresville, a shop for board game enthusiasts which also has an escape room.  He uses the shop as a way to connect with the community and share life and the love of Jesus with anyone he can.

 Mark Stair Worship Arts Minister markstair@valleymillscc.org

Mark Stair is our Worship Arts Minister. He joined our staff in the summer of 2018. He is a graduate of Milligan college and is married to his wife JJ. He has a passion for serving the Lord and believes God has called him into ministry. Some of his favorite hobbies include photography, making videos, running and watching movies. Forming and maintaining lasting relationships is an important part of Mark’s life as he realizes life is not meant to be done on your own. Mark and his wife JJ also have a Young Adult life group that meets periodically throughout the year. If you would like to contact him or have any questions feel free to do so through his email at markstair@valleymillscc.org.